Primo Oval XL vs. Other Ceramic Kamado Grills: Which Is the Best Kamado Grill of 2025?
If you’re searching for the best kamado grill in 2025, you’ve probably seen the names Primo Oval, Big Green Egg, and Kamado Joe pop up again and again. With so many choices, what really sets these ceramic grills apart—and which one is right for your outdoor kitchen? Let’s break it down with real-life cooking scenarios and a side-by-side look at the features that matter most.
What Makes the Primo Oval XL Stand Out?
Unique Oval Shape for Real Two-Zone Cooking
The Primo Oval’s patented oval design isn’t just for looks—it’s a game-changer for backyard chefs. Unlike traditional round kamados, the oval shape lets you set up true two-zone cooking. Imagine grilling steaks over direct heat on one side while slow-smoking veggies or ribs on the other. One of our Clermont customers loves hosting family BBQs and routinely smokes a full packer brisket or up to 10 racks of ribs—no cutting or cramming required. That’s a real advantage you’ll notice every time you fire it up.
Largest Cooking Area in Its Class
With over 400 square inches of primary cooking space (expandable to 680+ with optional racks), the Primo Oval XL is built for entertaining. Whether you’re prepping burgers for a birthday party or cooking multiple dishes for a holiday feast, you’ll appreciate the extra room. In comparison, the Kamado Joe Classic II and Big Green Egg (Large) offer 250 and 262 square inches, respectively—great for everyday use, but limiting when you want to go big.
Superior Build & Made in the USA
Primo grills are proudly crafted in the USA using premium ceramics. This means excellent heat retention, moisture, and flavor every single cook. The high-sitting lid gives you the space to vertically roast whole chickens or turkeys—perfect for Sunday dinners or Thanksgiving gatherings. Many customers tell us they chose Primo for the peace of mind that comes with American craftsmanship and a lifetime warranty. Added bonus, these won't be affected by tariffs since they are made domestically.
Versatile Cooking Styles
Grill, bake, roast, or smoke—the Primo Oval XL handles it all. The split, reversible cooking grids and divided charcoal basket make it easy to switch between cooking styles. Whether you’re baking a pizza at 800°F or slow-smoking pulled pork at 225°F, you’ve got the flexibility to master any recipe.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Grill Model | Cooking Area (sq in) | Shape | Key Features | Pros | Cons | Real-Life Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primo Oval XL | 400 (expandable to 680) | Oval | Split reversible grates, premium ceramic, adjustable dampers, made in USA | Versatile cooking, large area, great heat retention | Heavier, learning curve | Family cookouts with mixed grilling & smoking; baking pizzas and roasting chickens |
| Primo XXL All-In-One | 525 (expandable to 900) | Oval | Split reversible grates, high dome lid, locking casters, made in USA | Extra large space, ideal for big gatherings, versatile | Large footprint, higher price | Hosting backyard parties, cooking multiple dishes at once |
| Primo Large Charcoal | 300 (expandable to 495) | Oval | Split reversible grates, cast iron vent, made in USA | Compact size, good heat retention, easy control | Smaller area, fewer accessories | Small family dinners, quick grilling sessions |
| Primo Large Round Charcoal | 280 | Round | Split reversible grates, cast iron vent, made in USA | Classic shape, good heat retention, versatile | Smaller area, less space than oval models | Weekend grilling, smoking ribs, roasting vegetables |
What Do Real Grillers Say?
Reviewers and backyard chefs alike praise the Primo Oval XL for its flexibility and sheer capacity—especially for big cooks like whole briskets or multiple racks of ribs. Many highlight the oval shape as a major advantage for two-zone cooking, making it easier and more effective than on round kamados. And for those who value American-made products, Primo’s domestic manufacturing is a big plus.
In side-by-side tests, the Primo Oval XL often comes out ahead for those who prioritize versatility and cooking space. That said, all three grills deliver excellent results—so it comes down to what matters most for your style of entertaining.
Why Choose the Primo Oval XL for 2025?
If you want a kamado grill that can truly do it all—grill, smoke, roast, and bake—while offering the most flexibility and space, the Primo Oval XL is hard to beat. Its patented oval design, generous cooking area, and American craftsmanship make it a top contender for anyone serious about outdoor cooking.
Key Takeaways:
- True two-zone cooking with the oval shape
- Largest cooking area among leading ceramic kamados
- Made in the USA with premium materials
- Excellent for both everyday grilling and large gatherings
Final Thoughts
When you’re ready to invest in a kamado grill, think about how you like to cook and who you love to gather with. Whether you’re a backyard enthusiast or a seasoned pitmaster, the Primo Oval XL is designed to help you create lasting memories and mouthwatering meals for years to come.
Ready to experience the difference? Explore the Primo Oval XL at Ember & Oasis and take your outdoor cooking to the next level.